Internationalisation in the Digital Transformation: Strategies of German higher education institutions (INDISTRA)

Start of the project: 2021-Dec-01 - End of the project: 2024-Nov-30

Digitisation is driving a profound change in structures and processes within higher education institutions and at the same time, opens up scope for action for them. Digitisation not only makes it possible to increase the efficiency and quality of existing processes; central issues such as the organisation of studies, higher education teaching and the administration of student and academic mobility can be fundamentally rethought. These changed requirements and the corresponding structural adjustments also affect the area of internationalisation of higher education institutions. Before the upheavals initiated by the Covid-19 pandemic, the opportunities offered by digitisation for internationalisation in higher education were only used with relative restraint. Largely unexplored at present is how the massive increase in digitisation brought about by the pandemic has influenced and will influence the internationalisation strategies of public German higher education institutions.

The research agenda of this project focuses on the question of how internationalisation is understood and managed by higher education institutions as a digitally supported development opportunity and what goals, opportunities and risks higher education institutions associate with digitisation in this context. The aim of the project is to identify the strategic perspective of higher education institutions and their bodies and organisational units responsible for internationalisation (vice presidencies/prorectorates; international offices, academic international offices, departments.

The project is guided by the following research questions:

  • How does digitisation affect the internationalisation strategies of German higher education institution and their implementation in teaching and studies?
  • What effects does digitisation have on the administrative dimension of the internationalisation strategy, i.e. the planning and implementation of digital support processes?
  • What are the consequences of the digitalisation of internationalisation for decision-making and cooperation processes in higher education institutions?
  • How do the respondents assess the current and future development of the digitisation strategy in the area of internationalisation?
  • To answer these questions, the study chooses a qualitative mixed-methods approach, which includes a discourse analysis of relevant policy documents, expert interviews with those responsible for the development and implementation of internationalization strategies, and group interviews with representatives of foreign cooperating universities and teachers.

    With regard to the projects’ objectives, focusing on higher education institutions' strategies for integrating digital opportunities into their internationalisation strategies will contribute to closing an existing research gap. In addition, conclusions can be derived from the results that are relevant for the further design of political, funding policy and higher education strategies for the use of digital instruments in the field of international exchange at higher education institutions.

Show more Show less
Publications

Internationalisation in the digital transformation: A scoping review.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2023).
Internationalisation in the digital transformation: A scoping review. Higher Education Quarterly, 2023, 1-18 (online first). https://doi.org/10.1111/hequ.12488
Abstract

This scoping review aims to trace the evidence in the international scientific literature on the intersections between COVID-driven digitalisation and the internationalisation strategies of higher education institutions (HEIs). The focus lies on teaching and learning, cooperation, support structures, and leadership processes. We reviewed 45 studies from an initial selection of 648 sources retrieved from Scopus and Web of Science. Results showed that digitally supported internationalisation strategies are often associated with more cost-effective, inclusive and sustainable models. Despite ongoing calls for comprehensive approaches, the systematic adoption of virtual internationalisation strategies remains largely a normative subject.

How to Unite Contradictory Visions of Sustainable Internationalization.

Vögtle, E. M., & Ferreira Santos, L. (2023).
How to Unite Contradictory Visions of Sustainable Internationalization. IAU Horizons, 28(1), 50-51.
Abstract

While demands for sustainable models of internationalization are a recurring theme in the debates on internationalization, it cannot be assumed that shared meanings underlie these discussions and proposed solutions. In the realm of the project INDISTRA, this opinion piece discusses how different understandings and drivers of internationalization might be at odds as HEIs are called to rethink their strategies and practices toward sustainable internationalization and provides some key strategies for implementing sustainable internationalization of HEIs.

The ‘Global South’ in the transnational student mobility network. Effects of institutional instability, reputation of the higher education systems, post-colonial ties, and culture.

Vögtle, E. M., & Windzio, M. (2022).
The ‘Global South’ in the transnational student mobility network. Effects of institutional instability, reputation of the higher education systems, post-colonial ties, and culture. Globalisation, Societies and Education (online first). https://doi.org/10.1080/14767724.2022.2047900
Abstract

In this article, we take a global perspective and analyse how state institutions constitute a countries’ place in the global network of transnational student mobility. We use longitudinal social network analysis to investigate transnational student mobility patterns and find that fragile institutions act as a push factor by increasing outbound student mobility. In addition, reputation of a higher education system impacts on the countries’ role as a favoured study destination. And, particularly for countries in the Global South, cultural similarity is important for the intensity and direction of exchange within the global network of transnational student mobility.

Presentations

Internationalisierung in der Digitalen Transformation - Projekt INDISTRA.

Vögtle, E. (2024, Oktober).
Internationalisierung in der Digitalen Transformation - Projekt INDISTRA. Vortrag auf dem Seminar Neue Trends und Rahmenbedingungen in der Internationalisierung und im internationalen Austausch, iDA-Internationale DAAD-Akademie, DAAD Bonn, Deutschland.

Towards comprehensive digitalization – An investigation of virtual internationalization in German higher education.

Ferreira Santos, L., & Berg, J. (2024, September).
Towards comprehensive digitalization – An investigation of virtual internationalization in German higher education. Vortrag auf der Konferenz 19. Jahrestagung der Gesellschaft für Hochschulforschung (GfHf) „Die Zukunft der Hochschule: global, nachhaltig und inklusiv“, Fernuniversität Hagen, Hagen.
Abstract

Our presentation combines the findings of a thematic analysis of expert interviews with heads of international offices with the result of a document analysis of internationalization and digitalization strategies of German higher education institutions. We address two main questions: First, what are the main objectives of virtualizing higher education internationalization? And second, how can those objectives be linked to multiple factors that shape actions, strategies and outcomes of higher education governance? We focus mainly on competition and values-based governance. Both aspects are connected to expectations and practical challenges for the management of the internationalization of higher education.

Coping with Challenges in North-South Partnerships: A Selected Case Study of a German-Brazilian Joint Degree Program.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2024, September).
Coping with Challenges in North-South Partnerships: A Selected Case Study of a German-Brazilian Joint Degree Program. Poster auf der Konferenz 36th CHER Conference “Higher Education and Science Future(s): Trends, Imaginaries, and Alternatives”, University of Luxembourg, Luxembourg, Luxembourg.
Abstract

In this poster presentation, I shared my ongoing dissertation project investigating a Joint Degree Program (JDP) between a German and a Brazilian higher education institution. Drawing on Decolonial theorists and Schimank’s Actor Constellation Theory, the research questions examine the perspectives of management on the role of North-South international higher education partnerships in shaping strategic goals, the perceived challenges, institutional responses, as well as the environmental and organizational conditions that influence the operation of the selected case.

Coping with challenges in North-South international higher education partnerships: A selected case study of a German-Brazilian joint degree program.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2024, Juli).
Coping with challenges in North-South international higher education partnerships: A selected case study of a German-Brazilian joint degree program. Poster im Rahmen des EERA Summer School on Educational Research in Europe: decolonise, democratise and develop. Legacies and futurities, Universuty of Porto, Portugal.
Abstract

The poster presentation was aimed at sharing new insights gained into my dissertation projects following a week of exchanges and reflections around the topics of decoloniality and democratization of research practice.

Multiple Competitions and Social Values as Facilitators of Virtual Internationalization – Evidence from German Higher Education.

Berg, J., & Ferreira Santos, L. (2024, Mai).
Multiple Competitions and Social Values as Facilitators of Virtual Internationalization – Evidence from German Higher Education. Vortrag auf der Konferenz European Network on International Student Mobility: Connecting Research and Practice, Business & Technology University, Tbilisi, Georgia.
Abstract

Our presentation combines the findings of a content analysis of expert interviews with heads of international offices with the result of a document analysis of internationalization and digitalization strategies of German higher education institutions. We address two main questions: First, what are the main objectives of virtualizing higher education internationalization? And second, how can those objectives be linked to multiple factors that shape actions, strategies and outcomes of higher education governance? We focus mainly on competition and values-based governance. Both aspects are connected to expectations and practical challenges for the management of internationalization of higher education.

Virtual Participation.

Berg, J., & Ferreira Santos, L. (2024, Mai).
Moderation der Podiumsdiskussion Virtual Participation auf der Konferenz European Network on International Student Mobility: Connecting Research and Practice, Business & Technology University, Tbilisi, Georgia.

Why digitalize? An Investigation of Virtual Internationalization Governance in German Higher Education, based on peer-reviewed paper submission (Berg, J. & Ferreira Santos, L.).

Berg, J., & Ferreira Santos, L. (2024, März).
Why digitalize? An Investigation of Virtual Internationalization Governance in German Higher Education, based on peer-reviewed paper submission (Berg, J. & Ferreira Santos, L.). Vortrag auf der Konferenz Future of Higher Education - Bologna Process Researchers' Conference (FOHE-BPRC5) - Session 4: Digitalization and the future of European Higher Education: Implications for public policies, The Executive Agency for Higher Education, Research, Development and Innovation Funding (UEFISCDI), in partnership with the National University of Political Studies and Public Administration (SNSPA) and University of Bucharest (UB), Bucharest , Romania.
Abstract

Based on a multimodal understanding of governance in German higher education, we aim to investigate the multiple objectives and factors that shape the digitalization of higher education internationalization. We find that while values-based and competition-related approaches often motivate higher education institutions to embrace digitalization; the implementation is rather shaped by hierarchy and collegial governance factors. We suggest understanding digitalization as a comprehensive approach intertwined with all levels and modes of governance in higher education.

Covid-driven digitalization and comprehensive internationalization strategies in higher education: A scoping review.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2023, Oktober).
Covid-driven digitalization and comprehensive internationalization strategies in higher education: A scoping review. Poster auf der Konferenz "The Future of Higher Education and Science - A Turn of the Times?", German Centre for Higher Education Research and Science (DZHW) and Leibniz Center for Science and Society (LCSS), Hannover, Deutschland.
Abstract

The poster presentation at the DZHW/LCSS Conference 2023 aimed at sharing the findings of a scoping review conducted in the context of the project Internationalization in the Digital Transformation – INDISTRA. The study reviews international scientific literature on the intersections between COVID-driven digitalization and the internationalization strategies of higher education institutions. The focus lies on teaching and learning, cooperation, support structures, and leadership processes.

Covid-driven digitalization and comprehensive internationalization strategies in higher education: A scoping review.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2023, August/September).
Covid-driven digitalization and comprehensive internationalization strategies in higher education: A scoping review. Poster auf der Konferenz CHER 35th Annual Conference - Higher Education Institutions as Change Agents in Society: Perspectives on Adaptation and Impact, Vienna University of Economics and Business, Institute of Higher Education Management, Wien, Österreich.
Abstract

The poster presentation at the CHER Conference 2023 aimed at sharing the findings of a scoping review conducted in the context of the project Internationalization in the Digital Transformation – INDISTRA. The study reviews international scientific literature on the intersections between COVID-driven digitization and the internationalization strategies of higher education institutions. The focus lies on teaching and learning, cooperation, support structures, and leadership processes.

Internationalization in the Digital Transformation: A scoping review.

Ferreira Santos, L., & Vögtle, E. M. (2023, Februar).
Internationalization in the Digital Transformation: A scoping review. Vortrag in der DAAD Wissenschaftswerkstatt, DAAD, Bonn.
Abstract

The scoping review conducted in the context of the project Internationalization in the Digital Transformation – INDISTRA, analyses 45 scientific journal articles published in English between June 2017 and June 2022. The study draws on international scientific literature to trace the evidence available on the intersections between covid-driven digitization and its systematic integration into the internationalization strategies of higher education institutions. The focus of the scoping review lies on teaching and learning, cooperation, administration, and decision-making processes.

International Academic Partnerships (IAP) and the impact of digitalization in the establishment of joint programs between German and Brazilian institutions of higher education.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2022, September).
International Academic Partnerships (IAP) and the impact of digitalization in the establishment of joint programs between German and Brazilian institutions of higher education. Vortrag auf dem Seminar 7th HERSS Summer School "Transformation of Higher Education", zhb Center for Higher Education, TU Dortmund, Dortmund.
Abstract

In the field of internationalization of higher education, the establishment of joint programs is described as 'particularly problematic', due to the strong coordination efforts required. Yet, in a context of growing internationalization and digitalization, the online delivery of such programs is 'not only possible but desirable' (Joughin et al., 2022, p.829). At the HERSS Summer School, I discussed the prospects of investigating the setting up and implementation of digitally assisted-joint programs between German and Brazilian universities as the thematic focus of my Ph.D. research.

Science Diplomacy - Quo Vadis? Konsequenzen geopolitischer Konflikte für (multilaterale) Wissenschaftsmobilität.

Blümel, C., & Vögtle, E. M. (2022, September).
Workshop Science Diplomacy - Quo Vadis? Konsequenzen geopolitischer Konflikte für (multilaterale) Wissenschaftsmobilität auf dem Workshop Science Diplomacy - Quo Vadis? Konsequenzen geopolitischer Konflikte für (multilaterale) Wissenschaftsmobilität, DZHW, Berlin, Deutschland.
Abstract

The war in Ukraine has not only ushered in a "turning point" in military terms. This conflict also has far-reaching consequences for academic mobility and transnational academic cooperation - both for strategies and concepts in international research and academic policy and for research on academic exchange and multilateral cooperation between universities. In a joint workshop with representatives of science exchange organisations, the Federal Ministry of Education and Research, the Federal Foreign Office, parliamentarians and scientists, we discuss these consequences for science and politics.

Governance von Hochschulen, Definition, Modelle und aktuelle Entwicklungen.

Vögtle, E. (2022, August).
Governance von Hochschulen, Definition, Modelle und aktuelle Entwicklungen. Impulsvortrag im Rahmen des fzs Summercamp zum Thema Demokratie an der Hochschule, Freier Zusammenschluss von Student*innenschaften (fzs) e.V, Garrel-Petersfeld, Deutschland.
Abstract

The governance of higher education and science, understood as coordination and decision-making mechanisms, faces the challenge of increasingly taking social values into account. Societal values such as justice, equality or sustainability are brought to universities and research institutions by a wide range of stakeholders. This leads to value orientations external to science finding their way into evaluation processes and even into the design of scientific agendas via the way governance processes are conducted. Current approaches see universities as prototypes of evolutionary organisations consisting of self-managing teams that are responsive to societal values.

The INDISTRA project in the light of the new geopolitics of higher education.

Ferreira Santos, L. (2022, Juni).
The INDISTRA project in the light of the new geopolitics of higher education. Vortrag im Rahmen des Workshops by Katja Brøgger, Associate Professor, Danish School of Education, auf dem Seminar The New Geopolitics of Higher Education, Aarhus University, Denmark.
Abstract

The resurgence of all sorts of anti-globalization movements has produced huge repercussions in society, and institutions of higher education alike ( (Brøgger, 2021; Brooks, 2022; Habib, 2022; van der Vende, 2021). Knowing that the future of higher education internalization relies strongly on the way countries’ cross-border exchange will evolve (Lee, 2021), my participation in the Course The New geopolitics of Higher Education was aimed at reflecting on the research questions guiding the INDISTRA project (Internationalization and the Digital Transformation) in the light of current geopolitical debates; in particular, how the rise of neo-nationalisms is shaping new discourses and practices in higher education.

Conferences

Science Diplomacy - Quo Vadis? Konsequenzen geopolitischer Konflikte für (multilaterale) Wissenschaftsmobilität.

Blümel, C., & Vögtle, E. M. (2022, September).
Workshop Science Diplomacy - Quo Vadis? Konsequenzen geopolitischer Konflikte für (multilaterale) Wissenschaftsmobilität auf dem Workshop Science Diplomacy - Quo Vadis? Konsequenzen geopolitischer Konflikte für (multilaterale) Wissenschaftsmobilität, DZHW, Berlin, Deutschland.
Abstract

The war in Ukraine has not only ushered in a "turning point" in military terms. This conflict also has far-reaching consequences for academic mobility and transnational academic cooperation - both for strategies and concepts in international research and academic policy and for research on academic exchange and multilateral cooperation between universities. In a joint workshop with representatives of science exchange organisations, the Federal Ministry of Education and Research, the Federal Foreign Office, parliamentarians and scientists, we discuss these consequences for science and politics.

Contact person

Eva Maria Vögtle
Dr. Eva Maria Vögtle +49 511 450670-359

Researchers

Luzia Ferreira Santos

In cooperation with

Deutscher Akademischer Austausch Dienst

Funded by

Auswärtiges Amt